We have all had at least one experience of poor or bad leadership. I could add “unfortunately” at the end of that sentence? In most cases it is a learning lesson for the employee to avoid such leaders and their behaviour in the future. In other words, it teaches a very good lesson and makes us wiser in our future job searches and appointments. What about the organisation, is it unfortunate for them? The answer is most likely “yes” for the obvious reasons such as loss of good employees, poor morale that leads to low employee engagement, low productivity and ultimately increased sickness and absenteeism. The 2022 Gallup poll stated that “60% of employees are disengaged at a cost of US$8.8 trillion to business globally.” If that doesn’t make your ears prick up or hair stand on end, then I don’t know what will.
What are the top-rated worst leadership behaviours according to a survey conducted by Bamboo HR of 1000 employees:
| Your boss takes credit for your work | 63% |
| Your boss doesn’t trust or empower you | 62% |
| Your boss doesn’t care if you are overworked | 58% |
| Your boss doesn’t advocate for you when it comes to compensation | 57% |
| Your boss hires and/or promotes the wrong people | 56% |
| Your boss doesn’t back you up when there is a dispute | 55% |
| Your boss doesn’t provide proper direction on assignment/roles | 54% |
| Your boss micromanages and doesn’t allow you freedom to work | 53% |
| Your boss focuses more on your weaknesses than strengths | 53% |
| Your boss doesn’t set clear expectations | 52% |
On top of these reasons, Gallup together with Workhuman in a survey conducted in May 2023 established an extensive connection between employee recognition and wellbeing, finding that “employees who receive the right amount of recognition for the work they do suffer from lower burnout, enjoy improved daily emotions and stronger relations with their co-workers.”
What does Gallup consider to be wellbeing? This is divided into different aspects of wellbeing:
- Community
- Social
- Financial
- Career
- Physical
I agree that wellbeing is not just physical, wellbeing is much more than that, infact it is holistic just as Gallup has highlighted. The way I explain wellbeing is physical (vitality, energy, strength) mental (clarity, cognition, concentration), emotional (resilience, inner balance, positivity, self-compassion), and spiritual (purpose, alignment, integrity). In the Gallup survey these different aspects of wellbeing, in turn are placed into three buckets:
- Thriving Wellbeing – High wellbeing across most elements
- Suffering Wellbeing – A mix of high, medium or low elements
- Struggling Wellbeing – Low wellbeing across most elements
What then is the link between leadership and thriving employee wellbeing? According to Gallup and Workhuman – it is what they term “Strategic Recognition”. This is the ability to use the technique of giving genuine recognition to all employees. To be strategic it needs to:
- Meet employee expectations. In other words, be given in a timely manner and for the work that the employee thinks deserves recognition.
- Be authentic and genuine and not something that is simply on a to do list to be done every day.
- Personalised – given fairly to all without showing favouritism.
- Equitable – taking the needs of each individual into consideration rather than a one size fits all.
- Is part of the organisation culture and is lived throughout the organisation by all in everything they do.
The interesting point here is that giving recognition to an employee for doing a good job, costs nothing, there is no pay check attached, bonus or increase of some kind. It is a simple act of human, respect, gratitude and quiet celebration of an individual’s performance. The result when recognition is given authentically is an employee who feels valued for what they do, resulting in willingly doing more of the same. This in turn leads to increased engagement and productivity, less employees actively searching for a job and therefore increased retention, not forgetting the ultimate aim of decreasing sickness, both mental and physical, and absenteeism because employees thrive within the organisation culture.
So what you might ask? A Harvard Business Review survey on the impact of poor leadership behaviours revealed that:
- 48% of employees intentionally decreased their work effort.
- 47% intentionally decreased the time spent at work.
- 38% intentionally decreased the quality of their work.
- 63% lost work time trying to avoid the offender.
- 66% said that their performance declined.
- 78% said that their commitment to the organization declined.
- 25% admitted to taking their frustrations out on customers.
Give me an example of any organisation leadership that would not want to turn employee performance around to stop damaging their business? I hope that all organisations would want to turn this around and create a thriving workforce who love what they do. This requires a change in leadership behaviour to those that embrace their employees and encourage top performance through strategic recognition. Does this mean that all employees perform well? Probably not, but that doesn’t mean that a manager and leader should see this as requiring discipline, severe correction or even some kind of abuse. It is an opportunity to understand why and consequently turn the employee’s performance round to one of excellence. In my opinion there are no such thing as bad employees, only bad managers.
What behaviours do managers and leaders need to increase? Start by giving genuine authentic feedback and strategic recognition. This means “managing by walking about”, a concept that I learned in my early 20’s. By doing this you become human and approachable, you also know your employees by name and see how they perform, at the rock face while experiencing their daily work lives and not just seeing their names on a report or computer screen.
Not all managers and leaders have received appropriate training to know when and how to deliver feedback. Ask yourself: “What is the damage and cost to your business for not investing in your leaders to provide the necessary training in leadership and these vital skills?
Start the leadership training today, let’s talk.
References:
GREAT LEADERSHIP IN ACTION
THE MEANING OF LEADERSHIP
LEADERSHIP VS TECHNOLOGY
Rachel Shackleton is an entrepreneur who owns and manages Green Key Personal Development and Green Key Health. Working with local and multinational organisations, she is a public speaker and trainer in the spheres of leadership, communication and customer excellence. She ensures sustainable productivity and profitability through healthy self-management and leadership practices, ensuring a focused and successful workforce.